sometimes i wonder why i like english teachers so much. the good ones (shoutout natlaie redhead) spend their days helping kids come to their own conclusions about things. it was a breath of fresh air to be asked to make up my own mind in a school otherwise busy shoving necessities into my head for reasons that stretched from vague to dubious.
in psychology there’s a broad concept of constructivism, the basic tenet of which is that people (omg fuck screw english phrasing sometimes) are better off making their own understanding of themselves and their world through experiences, as opposed to having it handed to them and accepted. subjectivity, not objectivity. experience over information. the idea formed narrative therapy (examining and rebuilding the stories we tell ourselves), CBT (cognitive behavioural therapy, which acknowledges the idea that behaviour can change belief and the mind as well as vice versa), growth mindset (the skill of seeing all experiences in helpful contexts).
it rests on a basic positive anthropology in that it gives people agency and assumes their ability to help themselves.
constructivism is at odds with an older more rigid and negative view that people can’t be trusted and need to be controlled. an objective truth must be maintained and fed. thankfully we’re living in an age that rejects this more or less, but it’s still a part of life and i’ve always riled at the smell of it.
“but what does it mean”
the best art is also constructivist, sparking questions and curiosity rather than dictating meaning. the absolute peak is when a viewer can come out of a movie having been touched and impacted in a way unintended - because they were trusted to understand things in their own way. they were participants in the movie because they weren’t told what to think or feel. the meaning was constructed subjectively.
as screenwriting for dummies probably said, “show, don’t tell.”
i struggle to connect with people who prefer objective life. they want to talk about the news, the plumbing, their backyard, their cousin. their worldview is inherited, their rights and wrongs the same as their parents and friends. they fit in perfectly but may not have had a thought of their own?
conversely, i have deep admiration for people who thrive in a system that (let’s be honest) tends to prefer path-following, while also building their own ideas that go against the tide.
i have actually forgotten where i was going with this.
i know it’s about ai, using it well. i guess it’s just me harping on about the importance of experience. using ai to jump to the end isn’t just bad because it’s not human or whatever. it’s that the end is assumed, and people have no chance to develop understanding of their own.
but i’m not going to be scary and say we’re doomed - because i’m always surprised at the people’s preference to accept external influence and be samey. i guess we know deep down that it’s safer to be normal. and it’s true for most. parents know it too. and as we live in a world where even rats wouldn’t breed, it seems pragmatic to follow the breadcrumbs.
i think ai will increase our understanding of what it is to be human. by showing us the opposite, we can clearly see how much we need play, need mistakes. it’s not all about security and safety, it’s also the joy of being human, the pleasure of being alive and more than a means to an end…. more than your bank accounts K/D ratio, more than your birth certificate. And that ultiamtely self-realised humans
without understanding, we don’t know what is correct. it’s useless to be provided with an answer if we have no way to know if it’s right. actually it’s even worse if it is right, because in implementing it we will encounter less resistence and learn nothing about the problem being solved.
little ramble there you’re welcome.


